Creating a website design RFP (Request for Proposal) is a pivotal step for any business serious about investing in an effective digital presence. A well-prepared RFP not only attracts talented design agencies but also sets clear expectations, helping avoid costly mistakes and ensuring a smooth project from start to finish. Below is a comprehensive checklist of essential components you should include in your RFP to achieve the best results.
Image source: pexels.com
Define Your Project Scope Clearly
One of the most common pitfalls in website design projects is an unclear project scope. Businesses often submit RFPs that vaguely state “we want a new website,” leaving agencies to guess at functionality, features, and complexity. This ambiguity leads to proposals that vary wildly in pricing and approach, making it hard to compare vendors.
Instead, list exactly what pages you need (e.g., homepage, product pages, blog, contact forms), any specific integrations (CRM, email marketing platforms, payment gateways), and desired features such as animations or interactive elements. For example, if you run an e-commerce business, mention requirements like cart functionality, product filters, and user account systems. The clearer your scope, the more accurate and comparable the proposals will be.
To execute this step, start by auditing your current website. List all existing pages and note what works and what doesn’t. Sketch wireframes or simple page outlines to help visualize your future site structure. This doesn’t have to be a designer-level document—it simply needs to communicate your vision.
Establish Goals and KPIs
According to Thrive Internet Marketing Agency, a website redesign isn’t just a creative exercise—it’s a business investment meant to achieve specific outcomes. Unfortunately, many companies skip defining measurable goals in their RFP, leaving designers unsure how to prioritize design decisions for business impact.
Be precise about your objectives. Do you want to increase leads by 30%? Improve mobile usability scores? Reduce bounce rates? For instance, a SaaS company might state its goal is to boost demo signups, while a law firm may prioritize improving local search visibility and contact form submissions.
To implement this, brainstorm with your marketing and sales teams. Analyze existing analytics data to pinpoint pain points and opportunities. Document these goals clearly in your RFP, specifying how you’ll measure success (e.g., Google Analytics metrics, heatmaps, user testing feedback).
Detail Your Target Audience
Designing a website without a clear audience in mind is like building a house without a blueprint. Many RFPs simply say “our audience is everyone,” which leads to bland, generic designs that fail to resonate.
Instead, include detailed audience profiles. Describe demographics, interests, behaviors, and pain points. For example, a B2B software company might target mid-sized business owners who are tech-savvy but time-poor and require quick access to product demos and pricing information. Conversely, a non-profit might cater to donors who value storytelling and emotional engagement.
To execute this, create 2-3 buyer personas. Gather insights from customer interviews, sales feedback, and analytics. Note what messaging and visuals resonate with each segment. Include these findings in your RFP so designers can tailor layouts, calls-to-action, and imagery accordingly.
Specify Budget and Timeline Constraints
Many businesses fear that revealing a budget upfront will inflate vendor pricing. However, hiding your budget often wastes time on proposals far outside your range or on designs that can’t be achieved realistically.
Include at least a budget range in your RFP. For instance, “Our budget is between $25,000 and $35,000, excluding ongoing maintenance.” This helps vendors propose solutions that fit your resources rather than overselling.
Likewise, set a clear timeline. If you need your website launched before a major conference, say so. For example, “We need to launch by October 15th to coincide with our product rollout.” When executing this, work backward from your desired launch date, factoring in time for revisions and approvals.
Outline Technical Requirements
Technical details can make or break a project. Many RFPs neglect to mention platform preferences, hosting constraints, or integrations, resulting in costly surprises later. For example, you might prefer WordPress for easy updates, or you may have a complex backend system that requires custom development.
List preferred CMS platforms, hosting environments, security requirements, accessibility standards (e.g., WCAG 2.1 compliance), and integration needs like Salesforce, HubSpot, or custom APIs. For example, if you use HubSpot for email automation, state that the website must integrate seamlessly.
To complete this section, consult your IT team or any current vendors for documentation on systems your website must connect with. Include file formats for deliverables (e.g., layered PSDs, Figma files) to avoid misalignment with your internal workflows.
Ask for Relevant Work Samples and References
Design portfolios often look beautiful—but beauty alone doesn’t guarantee business results. Avoid costly mistakes by asking vendors to provide samples similar to your industry or project type. For example, if you’re a medical practice, request examples of healthcare sites they’ve designed, focusing on HIPAA compliance or patient portals.
Moreover, ask for case studies detailing how past work improved clients’ business metrics. References can also reveal how responsive and collaborative the agency is during projects.
To execute this, include a section in your RFP requesting at least three relevant work samples, brief descriptions of the projects, and two to three references you can contact. This helps you evaluate their capabilities beyond surface-level visuals.
Define the Proposal Submission Format
Chaos often ensues when different vendors submit proposals in vastly different formats. Some send simple emails, while others create elaborate slide decks, making them hard to compare side by side.
In your RFP, define precisely how you want proposals formatted. For example, ask vendors to submit their responses as a PDF document not exceeding 20 pages, structured into sections like company overview, approach, timeline, budget, and team bios.
To execute this, provide a table of contents template within your RFP. This ensures consistency and makes it easier to evaluate proposals objectively.
Following this checklist will help ensure your website design RFP attracts the right vendors, prevents costly surprises, and positions your project for success. By approaching your RFP strategically and including precise details, you’ll pave the way for a smoother partnership and a website that truly delivers results.